Skip to content
← Back to Latest News

Are We Solving the Same Problem?

by Valerie Harkins Lindsay, Housing SpecialistUntitled design 2

There is a subtle disconnect that can happen in maternity housing, and when it does, it can affect nearly every part of a resident’s experience in the home.

We may be trying to solve a problem the resident does not know she has.

Consider what happens before a woman ever arrives at a maternity home. When she chooses to carry her pregnancy to term, we rightly celebrate that decision. We affirm her courage. We remind her that her child is a gift and that pregnancy does not have to derail her future. We surround her with a life-affirming message: You can do this. Your baby is not the problem. There is help.

Then she arrives at a maternity home seeking that help.

Suddenly, she encounters curfews, required meetings, chores, budgeting, employment expectations, case management, parenting education, restrictions on guests or relationships, and other program requirements.

From our perspective, these things may make perfect sense. From hers, they may not.

She may reasonably wonder: I thought I needed somewhere safe to live while I had my baby. Why is everyone suddenly trying to change my life?

That question deserves our attention.

Compare It to a Recovery Program

Imagine someone entering a residential drug rehabilitation program.

On day one, there is at least one basic point of agreement between the resident and the program: drugs are causing a problem, and the resident needs help to stop using them.

The staff may understand addiction, trauma, coping mechanisms, relapse patterns, and behavioral triggers at a level the resident does not yet understand. But there is still a starting point:

Drugs are a problem. I am using drugs. I need help.

From there, the program can begin.

Maternity housing is different.

A woman may enter our home believing her problem is simple: I don’t have anywhere to live.

Meanwhile, staff may see unstable relationships, chronic unemployment, financial disorder, unresolved trauma, destructive coping mechanisms, or patterns of dependence that repeatedly lead to instability.

The immediate housing crisis is real. But the maternity home may be designed to address considerably more than the immediate crisis.

Have we ever actually agreed on what problem we are trying to solve?

If the Problem Is Housing, Why All the Rules?

This question helps us see the resident’s perspective.

If the only problem is that she lacks somewhere to sleep, then many maternity home requirements can seem unnecessary.

Why does having nowhere to live mean I need a curfew?

Why do I need a budget?

Why do I have to attend classes?

Why are you asking about my relationships?

Why do I need goals?

If the problem is simply housing, she has a point. A shelter or housing subsidy could address that problem with far fewer demands.

This is one reason a maternity home can feel “controlling” to a resident even when the staff’s intention is anything but control.

Staff sees the connection between program expectations and long-term stability. The resident may not.

What staff calls structure, she experiences as restriction. What staff calls accountability, she experiences as punishment. What staff calls programming, she experiences as hoops she must jump through to keep a roof over her head.

The rules themselves may not be the problem. The missing piece may be the connection between the rules and the problem they are intended to help solve.

Without that connection, help can feel remarkably like a sentence.

Pregnancy Cannot Become the Problem

There is another tension here that maternity homes must handle carefully.

We cannot spend months telling a woman that her baby is not an obstacle to her future, only to create an environment that inadvertently communicates that becoming pregnant has landed her in a corrective institution.

There can be a kind of whiplash in that experience.

Before entering the home, her decision to carry her child is celebrated as courageous and life-affirming. After entering the home, she encounters an intensive program aimed at changing significant portions of her life.

But pregnancy is not the problem. Her baby is certainly not the problem.

Pregnancy may simply be the moment when other forms of instability became impossible to ignore.

It may expose the fragility of her housing situation, make an unhealthy relationship harder to tolerate, bring financial habits into sharper focus, or reveal how little support she actually has.

Pregnancy can illuminate instability without being its cause.

That distinction matters.

What Problem Is She Trying to Solve?

This may be one of the most important questions we can ask at intake: What problem are you hoping coming here will help you solve?

Then listen.

Her answer may be housing. It may be safety. It may be getting away from the baby’s father, keeping custody of her children, finding employment, or simply surviving the next few months.

Whatever the answer, that is likely where her motivation will initially live.

People invest energy into solving problems they actually believe they have.

We cannot expect a resident to invest tremendous effort into solving a problem that only the staff has identified.

That does not mean staff must agree with the resident’s assessment. Good case management helps people recognize patterns, consequences, strengths, and obstacles they may not yet see.

This step of awareness for her cannot be skipped.

We cannot identify the “real problem” in a staff meeting, build an entire service plan around it, and then become frustrated when the resident lacks enthusiasm for solving a problem no one has helped her recognize.

Finding the Point of Alignment

Before asking, How do we get her to engage with the program? Perhaps we should ask:

What does she believe needs to change? What do we believe needs to change? Where do those answers overlap?

This does not require abandoning standards, boundaries, or expectations. Maternity homes have a responsibility to maintain healthy environments and programs with integrity.

But there is an important difference between enforcing a rule and helping someone understand its purpose.

A resident who understands, I am working on this because it is connected to the life I want for myself and my child, is in a very different position from one who thinks, I have to do this because otherwise they will kick me out.

The behavior may look identical for a while. The formation is not.

Before the goal sheet, class, chore chart, or curfew, we need enough conversation to understand why she believes she is here and to help her understand why the program exists.

What brought you here?

What keeps happening that you don’t want to keep happening?

What would stability look like to you?

What stands between you and that life?

And eventually: Here is what we see. Do you see it too?

Maternity housing is not simply about providing a bed, nor is it about correcting a woman because she became pregnant. At its best, it creates a stable place from which a mother can build the life she wants for herself and her child.

But we cannot expect her to invest in a solution until we have taken the time to understand whether we are solving the same problem.